How a book was built in the 1990s and how it is built today
An IPO in 1996 and one in 2026 follow the same statute. Paper prospectuses, the quiet period, research, allocation and settlement have all changed,…
An initial public offering in 1996 and one in 2026 follow the same statute and reach the same result: a registration statement becomes effective, a price is agreed and shares are delivered. Most of what happens in between has changed, and nearly every change can be traced to a specific rule.
Paper
In the 1990s the preliminary prospectus, known as the red herring for the legend printed in red on its cover, was a physical document. It was typeset at a financial printer, where bankers, lawyers and company officers spent nights correcting proofs, and it was shipped in boxes to the syndicate’s sales offices.
The final prospectus was delivered on paper to every purchaser with the confirmation of sale. Delivery was a legal condition of the sale.
The SEC’s Securities Offering Reform of 2005 ended most of this. Under Rule 172, filing the final prospectus with the SEC satisfies the delivery obligation, a principle known as access equals delivery. The same reform created the free writing prospectus, which allows written offering material outside the statutory prospectus provided it is filed, and it permitted roadshows to be transmitted electronically.
The roadshow
A 1990s roadshow was a tour. Management visited the main institutional centers over two weeks, giving the same presentation at breakfasts, lunches and one-on-one meetings. Investors who were not in the room saw nothing.
Today a recorded version of the presentation is typically available online for the length of the marketing period, and many institutional meetings are held by video. The marketing period has shortened to match.
Who may speak, and when
The quiet period was stricter. Before a registration statement was filed, an issuer could not communicate with investors about the offering, and the consequence of a stray interview could be a delayed deal.
The JOBS Act of 2012 allowed emerging growth companies to test the waters with institutional investors before or after filing. In 2019 the SEC extended that to all issuers through Rule 163B. The JOBS Act also introduced confidential submission of draft registration statements for emerging growth companies, which the SEC staff extended to all issuers in 2017. A company can now resolve SEC comments and gauge institutional demand before the public knows it has filed.
Research
In the 1990s the research analyst at the lead underwriter was part of the sales effort. Analysts attended pitches, joined roadshows and were paid in part from investment banking revenue. Favorable coverage after the IPO was an understood part of what the issuer was buying.
The 2003 global settlement between regulators and ten large firms ended that arrangement. Research and investment banking were separated, analysts were barred from pitches and roadshows, and their compensation could no longer be tied to banking fees.
Allocation
Allocation was at the bookrunner’s discretion with little outside scrutiny. The practices that grew up in the late 1990s, among them allocating hot issues to executives of prospective banking clients, known as spinning, produced enforcement actions and new rules. FINRA Rule 5130 restricts sales of new issues to industry insiders, and Rule 5131 prohibits spinning.
Pricing and settlement
Shares were quoted in fractions until 2001, when decimal pricing arrived. Trades settled three business days after the trade date from 1995, two from 2017 and one from 2024. The underwriter’s exposure between pricing and closing has shrunk accordingly.
What has not changed
The liability is the same. Section 11 of the Securities Act still makes the issuer, its directors, the officers who sign and the underwriters liable for a material misstatement in the registration statement. The underwriter’s defense is still due diligence, and the diligence call, the comfort letter and the legal opinion are recognizably what they were.
The central judgment is also the same. At the end of the marketing period the bookrunner has a list of orders at various prices and must recommend one price to the issuer. Technology has changed how the list is assembled. The recommendation still rests on a view of which orders are real and which investors will hold.
Sponsor’s view
From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. I learned this business at Prudential Securities in the 1990s, when a deal moved at the speed of the printer. The rules since then have made offerings faster and marketing more open. Every one of those changes came with a filing requirement or a conduct rule attached. An issuer today has more freedom to speak to investors than my clients had then, and more ways to get it wrong.
Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.