FlotoReview
Underwriting

Why the largest IPOs pay the smallest spreads

The two largest IPOs in history paid underwriters less than 1% of proceeds. A $20 million IPO pays about 7%, plus warrants. Why the two prices differ and what a small issuer can negotiate.

Nov 21, 20264 min read
4min read
3sources
3topics
Nov 21published

The two largest IPOs in history paid their underwriters more than $1 billion between them this year, and both paid less than 1% of proceeds. A company raising $20 million on the Nasdaq Capital Market will pay about ten times that rate. Both figures come from how underwriting is priced.

The numbers

Reuters reported on Nov. 20, citing the final prospectus, that a syndicate of 22 banks will share about $550 million for underwriting Anthropic’s $81.3 billion offering. That is roughly 0.68% of the amount raised. The company is paying $536.7 million of it and seven selling co-founders the remaining $13.3 million. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, which led the deal, each take about a fifth of the pool. Fortune put that at $113 million apiece.

SpaceX’s $75 billion offering in June generated about $500 million in fees, a similar percentage.

The wider picture is in the New York State Comptroller’s report on Wall Street profits. Underwriting fees in the first half of 2026 were 68% higher than in the first half of 2025.

Why large deals pay less

The gross spread is the difference between the price the underwriters pay the issuer and the price at which they sell to the public. It covers three things: managing the deal, taking the risk of owning the shares, and the selling effort.

For an offering of this size all three are cheap relative to the proceeds. The selling effort is small when demand exceeds supply several times over. The underwriting risk is small when the book is covered before pricing. And the issuer has the bargaining power, because every bank wants the mandate. Reuters reported that some banks in the Anthropic syndicate did not learn what they would be paid until the night the deal priced, and recalled that Arm gave its 28 underwriters no clear fee arrangement in 2023.

Why small deals pay 7%

In 2000 the economists Hsuan-Chi Chen and Jay Ritter published a study titled “The Seven Percent Solution.” They found that the great majority of U.S. IPOs raising between $20 million and $80 million paid a gross spread of exactly 7%. The figure has proved durable. It remains the standard quotation for a small firm-commitment IPO.

The spread is only part of the cost. A small-cap underwriter typically also receives an expense allowance, reimbursement of legal fees up to a cap, and warrants to buy shares at a premium to the offering price. FINRA Rule 5110 requires underwriting compensation to be disclosed and reviewed for fairness, and it counts the warrants as compensation. Taken together, total underwriting compensation on a small deal is commonly well above the 7% headline.

The reasons are the reverse of the large-deal case. The selling effort is real, because the buyers have to be found one account at a time. The risk is real, because a small stock can trade below the offering price on the first day. And the issuer has little bargaining power, because few firms will take the mandate.

What an issuer can negotiate

The percentage rarely moves. Four other terms do.

  • The warrant coverage and its exercise price. These determine future dilution and are often more negotiable than the cash fee.
  • The right of first refusal. Many engagement letters give the underwriter the right to act on the company’s future financings. FINRA limits the term, and issuers can shorten it or carve out specific transactions.
  • The tail. A fee is often payable if the company completes a financing with investors the underwriter introduced, for a period after the engagement ends. The list of covered investors should be defined in writing.
  • The lock-up and any right to release it. These govern when insiders and early investors can sell.

The alternatives carry their own price

A company that avoids an underwritten IPO does not avoid cost. A direct listing has no gross spread, though the company pays a financial advisor and raises no capital on the day. A Regulation A offering sold through a broker-dealer carries a placement fee, with no underwriter standing behind the price. An equity line has no placement fee, and the cost is the discount at which the investor buys each draw.

The comparison an issuer should make is total cost of capital over the first two years as a public company, counting the spread, the warrants, the discount on later financings and the dilution each produces.

Sponsor’s view

From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. When I started in investment banking, seven percent was the price of a mid-sized IPO, and thirty years later it still is. The percentage has stayed the same for a small issuer. The attention belongs on the terms around it: the warrants, the right of first refusal and the tail. Those are the provisions that follow a company into its second and third financings, and they are the ones a first-time issuer most often signs without reading closely.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related